Question from AlexAlex:
One thing I've seen mentioned in the Harold audition talk is that work done outside of the audition can factor into who gets put on a team. Examples I've heard are things like performances in class, jams and indie shows. I'm wondering if the same is true of who gets put on a Maude team? Specifically writing, since that's what I'm interested in. Is that decision just based on the quality of our packet? Or can things like work we've done in class and/or sketch shows we've written for outside of the theater and/or things we've written that have had some success online also be a factor in deciding who gets put on a team?
Good question! As AD, I have conducted one Maude audition and am about to do my second Harold Audition, so I can only speak for how I've done it and how I plan to do it in the future.
The most important thing is this: the audition (in the case of Harold or actor on Maude) or the packet (for a writer on Maude). That trumps everything. Having an indisputably excellent audition or packet will get you on a team.
For the large pool of actors/writers who have a step below superb packets/auditions (let's call them "very good"), then yes, external things come into play to help break the tie. I looked through the teacher notes for all 300 writers who submitted and for upcoming Harold auditions I have already looked through the teacher notes for all 400+ people auditioning. I also ask teachers/coaches/directors for recommendations. All of this is factored in. A strong recommendation from a teacher isn't enough, but if you have a solid packet plus I've seen a great video you uploaded to UCBcomedy plus your teacher gave you great notes plus on your resume I see that you started a sketch comedy group in college, then that could be enough to edge you ahead of someone else who also had a solid packet.
Short answer: the packet/audition trumps all, but external factors are considered to break ties for the solid/very good packets/auditions. If you have a mediocre audition/packet though, even the best recommendations and external work wouldn't be enough to fix that. So you still need to do excellent work in the audition/packet.
Let me know if I can explain further.